By 1972, the mid-1960s explosion of American garage bands already felt like ancient radio. FM albums were getting longer; AM singles that had flared for a few weeks were being deleted, forgotten, or sold for pennies in used bins. Elektra Records founder Jac Holzman asked a New York writer and record-shop clerk named Lenny Kaye to assemble a list of those disappearing tracks. The result, released on October 2, 1972, was a double LP with a deliberately misspelled subtitle: Nuggets: Original Artyfacts from the First Psychedelic Era, 1965–1968.
It was not a greatest-hits package of the Summer of Love, and it was not a Texas history lesson. It was something rarer: a carefully sequenced argument that the mid-1960s American underground — fuzz guitar, Farfisa organ, regional hits, and a handful of genuine chart smashes — deserved to be heard as a body of work. Among its 27 songs was the 13th Floor Elevators’ “You’re Gonna Miss Me,” the Austin single that had already become the calling card of Roky Erickson and the Elevators. Half a century later, Nuggets is still the map many listeners use to find that world.
A clerk, a label head, and a double album
Kaye was working at Village Oldies in New York and writing about rock when Holzman pulled him into Elektra. In later interviews, including an NPR conversation on the compilation’s fiftieth anniversary, Kaye recalled being asked to assemble a list of songs — the kind of record that had slipped under the radar or been overlooked as an album track. Holzman called them nuggets. Kaye came back with a long list; the finished album held 27 cuts.
The original plan was more ambitious still. Kaye later said the project had been conceived as a series of roughly eight regional LPs. Elektra persuaded him that one double album would be easier to sell. A lawyer, Michael Kapp, was hired to track down rights. Even then, licensing was messy enough that a planned second Elektra volume never appeared, though Kaye kept lists of songs he had hoped to include. Those “might-have-beens” would surface, in different shapes, on later Rhino editions.
What the original 27 tracks actually were
Nuggets opens with the Electric Prunes’ “I Had Too Much to Dream (Last Night)” and the Standells’ “Dirty Water,” then threads through the Knickerbockers, the Seeds’ “Pushin’ Too Hard,” Count Five’s “Psychotic Reaction,” the Leaves’ “Hey Joe,” the Chocolate Watchband, Todd Rundgren’s early band Nazz, and, on side two, the Elevators. The set is often remembered as a stash of one-hit wonders. That memory is only half true. Mark Deming, writing for AllMusic, and later notes around the 1998 box set have pointed out that a substantial share of the original program had been American Top 40 material. The compilation’s real trick was juxtaposition: national hits next to regional cult records, all framed as evidence of one brief, combustible era.
The Elevators’ placement matters. “You’re Gonna Miss Me,” written by Erickson and first cut with his earlier Austin group the Spades, had been re-recorded with Tommy Hall’s electric jug and issued nationally on Houston’s International Artists; it reached the mid-50s on the Billboard charts in 1966. On Nuggets it sits not as a Texas footnote but as a peer of the California and Midwest garage singles that radio remembered more easily. For a fuller account of how that record was made, see our history of the Elevators and the electric jug and the documentary page for You’re Gonna Miss Me.
Kaye has been frank, in later interviews, that the finished album was broader than the “garage rock” category listeners now project onto it. Studio-minded tracks such as Sagittarius’ “My World Fell Down” sit beside rawer fuzz workouts. The word “garage” does not appear in his original liner notes. The phrase he did use — “punk rock” — is now cited as one of the earliest published appearances of the term, years before it named a mid-1970s movement. Kaye would soon become lead guitarist in the Patti Smith Group, which makes the 1972 compilation look, in hindsight, like a bridge rather than a museum piece.
Sire, Pebbles, and a cottage industry of crate-digging
Elektra did not turn Nuggets into an immediate franchise. Sire Records reissued the double album in 1976 with a new cover, just as a new generation of bands was scavenging mid-1960s singles for speed, sneer, and short-song discipline. Punk-era listeners treated the compilation as a usable past, not as nostalgia wallpaper.
Other compilers went further into the weeds. The first Pebbles LP appeared in 1978 (a limited Mastercharge pressing is often cited), and the series — closely associated with collector and Bomp! Records founder Greg Shaw — stretched across many later volumes of even more obscure regional recordings. Similar anthologies, including the Rubble and Back from the Grave series, followed the same instinct: if Nuggets had proved the bins still hid classics, maybe the next classic was on a private-press 45 from a town no major label had ever visited. A small-label economy grew up around that idea, with all the blessings and pitfalls of unofficial reissues that collectors still have to navigate.
The Rhino era, and a second life on CD and vinyl
In the 1980s, Rhino Records built a fifteen-part Nuggets series of albums organized by style or region. In 1998 the label issued the definitive-feeling 4-CD box: the original 27 tracks, in original order, plus 91 additional mid-1960s American recordings — 118 songs in all. That set folded in records that had become garage-canon after 1972, from the Music Machine’s “Talk Talk” and the Sonics’ “Strychnine” to Love’s “7 and 7 Is,” and it also made room for outright smashes such as Strawberry Alarm Clock’s “Incense and Peppermints.”
Rhino then widened the map. Nuggets II: Original Artyfacts from the British Empire and Beyond, 1964–1969 (2001) looked outside the United States, to the Pretty Things, the Easybeats, Os Mutantes, and other scenes. Children of Nuggets (2005) collected later bands that had treated the original set as a style manual. Scene-specific boxes followed, including Love Is the Song We Sing: San Francisco Nuggets 1965–1970 (2007) and Where the Action Is! Los Angeles Nuggets: 1965–1968 (2009). In 2012 the original album was remastered again from the 1972 tapes; in 2023 Rhino marked the project’s fiftieth anniversary with a 5-LP box that finally presented a Lenny Kaye-compiled Nuggets, Volume 2, built from songs he had earmarked in the early 1970s, plus a further disc of near-misses titled Also Dug-Its.
Why Nuggets still matters on a Texas psych site
For RokyMovie readers, Nuggets is more than a collector’s totem. It is one of the main reasons a 1966 International Artists single stayed in circulation for people who had never set foot in Austin. It placed the Elevators inside a national conversation about garage and psychedelia, and it did so in 1972 — after the band had collapsed, and long before Keven McAlester’s documentary or the later reissue boom made Erickson’s story widely visible. If you are just beginning to collect the records themselves, start with a legal, well-mastered edition of Nuggets and then read our guide to collecting 1960s psychedelic vinyl.
The compilation is also a reminder to be precise about language. “Psychedelic era,” in Kaye’s subtitle, covers a lot of American music that was rawer, funnier, and more regional than the San Francisco poster in the dorm-room imagination. The Elevators belong on that map. So do dozens of bands who never got a second single. The job Nuggets assigned itself — to listen again, and to take three-minute records seriously — is still the right way into the period.
Related: You’re Gonna Miss Me · Roky Erickson & the 13th Floor Elevators · The 13th Floor Elevators and the Electric Jug · How to Start Collecting 1960s Psychedelic Vinyl · Old Links & Press
Leave a Reply